25 live
Sun 22 Nov685 matches triangulated235 competitions3 Prime Picks today65.2% picks won · since 15 Nov25 live nowFree · no account · 18+
Every result →
Competition
USA US Open Cup
Kick-off
Thu 21 May GMT+1
Venue
ScottsMiracle-Gro Field
Status
Full time
HomeColumbus CrewWWLLD
1:0HT 0–0
1 · Columbus Crew53%
X · Draw24%
2 · New York City FC23%

Columbus Crew vs New York City FC prediction — 1X

FDVS verdictColumbus Crew or drawStrong · FDVS 77 · odds 1.22 · -6% vs fair
Home53%Draw24%Away23%
xG 2.1 – 1.3

Triangulation R = our team ratings · S = stats model · M = market, margin removed

OutcomeRSMFDVSAgree
Columbus Crew or draw pick778174773/3 agree
Columbus Crew win506149533/3 agree
Draw272025240/3 agree
New York City FC win231926230/3 agree
Over 2.5 goals488557632/3 agree
Under 2.5 goals521543371/3 agree
Both teams score516959593/3 agree

For 1X2 a view "agrees" when the outcome is its favourite; for two-way markets when it is above 50%. A dash means that view has no number for this match (for example, a team without enough rated games).

ATTACKDEFENCEFORMXGCLEAN SHEETSSCORING■ Columbus Crew▫ New York City FC

Scenario simulator move a slider – every market updates

Expected goals

MarketScenarioChange
Columbus Crew win
Draw
New York City FC win
Over 1.5
Over 2.5
Over 3.5
Both teams score

Likeliest scores:

The simulator starts from this match's expected goals (2.10–1.34) and redraws the full score grid in your browser. It is a what-if tool: the FDVS rating above also averages in the market, so the starting numbers can differ slightly.

Form last 5 · newest on the right · 90-minute scores

Columbus Crew
Last 5WWLLD2W 1D 2L · goals 11–8
At homeDWWWL10 pts of 15 · goals 11–6
New York City FC
Last 5LDWWD2W 2D 1L · goals 10–8
AwayLWWWD10 pts of 15 · goals 10–6
Our tipWon ✓
1XColumbus Crew or draw
FDVS rating
77
Price
1.22
Fair price
1.29
Edge
-6%
Likeliest score
2–1

Columbus Crew win or draw: 77%. Short at 1.22 – useful in a combination, thin on its own.

Prices against our chances

Fair = 100 ÷ our chance · edge = how far the price beats it
MarketPickPriceOur chanceFairEdge
Match result1 · Columbus Crew1.8853%1.880%
X · Draw3.6524%4.17-13%
2 · New York City FC3.5523%4.40-19%
Double chance1X desk1.2277%1.29-6%
121.2076%1.32-9%
X21.8547%2.14-14%
Goals 1.5Over 1.51.2082%1.22-2%
Under 1.54.2018%5.48-23%
Goals 2.5Over 2.51.6562%1.62+2%
Under 2.52.1538%2.61-18%
Goals 3.5Over 3.52.6040%2.48+5%
Under 3.51.4560%1.68-14%
Both teams to scoreGG1.5564%1.56-1%
NG2.2036%2.79-21%
Half-time result1 HT2.4042%2.39+1%
X HT2.2536%2.80-20%
2 HT3.8022%4.47-15%

Prices are the ones in our data when this page was built and move all day – check your bookmaker before you bet. 18+.

Quick accumulators

Ade Ola · FDVS

Who the numbers favour

Columbus Crew are in front, but not by much: 53% against 23%, with 24% for the draw.

Form going in

Recent run for Columbus Crew: D L L W W W, so three wins out of six. Latest: away at Philadelphia Union, 1–1. 2.2 goals a game is a strong return.

New York City FC arrive on D W W D L W, newest first (three wins in six). Latest: away at New York Red Bulls, 1–1. They are scoring freely – 2.5 a game.

Goals

We expect 2.1 goals from Columbus Crew and 1.3 from New York City FC, about 3.4 in all. That points to an open game: Over 2.5 comes out at 62% and GG at 64%.

Our pick (graded)

Before kick-off FDVS went with 1X (Columbus Crew or draw), FDVS rating 77 at a price near 1.22 – fair would be 1.29. If you want one scoreline, ours is Columbus Crew 2–1 New York City FC. Graded on the 90-minute score. 18+, stake only spare money.

Same day, same competition

League page
Embed this card on your site free · updates itself

Shows our three views, the pick and the Disagreement Index for this match, with a link back to this page. Add data-theme="dark" for dark sites. More on the widget page.

Match analysis: Columbus Crew vs New York City FC

Who did FDVS expect to win Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Before kick-off our numbers had Columbus Crew 53%, draw 24%, New York City FC 23%. Columbus Crew had the edge, but it is far from certain.

What is the FDVS pick for Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

1X (Columbus Crew or draw) with a FDVS rating of 77, priced around 1.22. FDVS 77 means picks like this win about 77 times in 100.

How many goals did FDVS expect in Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Our model expected about 3.4 goals: Over 2.5 at 62%, Over 1.5 at 82%.

Will both teams score in Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Both teams to score (GG) comes out at 64% – likely.

What is the likeliest score in Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

Columbus Crew 2–1 New York City FC – though any single exact score is always unlikely.

What time is Columbus Crew vs New York City FC?

00:30 GMT+1 on Thursday 21 May 2026 at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field (US Open Cup).